Center for Global Health R&D Policy Assessment

Follow us on:

Challenges for Innovation in TB Diagnostics

Lessons from a recent conference in Bangalore, India

A guest blog by Nora Engel and Madhukar Pai

A recent conference at St. John´s Research Institute (SJRI) in Bangalore brought together for the first time over 200 representatives from industry, government, donors, academia, hospitals, civil society and the media to discuss what it takes to innovate in TB diagnostics in India and to move from importation and imitation to innovation.

New diagnostic tests for TB are urgently needed to control the epidemic that continues to affect more than 9 million people every year. Existing tests are slow, insensitive or expensive and require highly specialized facilities which are difficult to provide in resource-poor countries such as India, where TB is rampant.

The diagnostic test currently used by the Indian TB programme (RNTCP) for routine TB cases is sputum smear microscopy; a technique developed over 100 years ago. It requires, despite its apparent simplicity and low cost, experience and skills to read the slides, has poor sensitivity (around 40% of TB cases go undetected) and is unable to diagnose multi-drug resistant forms of TB. By the time patients are identified as sputum smear-positive and initiated on therapy, they may have already infected 15 others in their community. In contrast to the public sector, sputum smears are underused in the vast, unregulated private sector in India which provides care for over half of all TB patients in the country. Instead, TB is often diagnosed with useless serological (antibody) tests that have been discouraged by the WHO. Furthermore, a vast majority of Indian laboratories have virtually no form of accreditation or quality standards.

Undiagnosed and poorly managed TB fuels the epidemic in India and is creating multi-drug resistance. Recognizing these challenges, the Government of India has set the ambitious goal of providing universal access to quality diagnosis and treatment to all TB patients. The Indian TB programme therefore needs new or improved tests to diagnose both drug-sensitive TB and MDR-TB. The conference in Bangalore was aimed at engaging the various stakeholders, especially Indian industry, to stimulate interest and investments in TB innovations.

The conference featured several panel discussions comprised of a mix of different stakeholders that highlighted the challenge of TB diagnostics from its different angles and facets. It seems that the ideal diagnostic test would be a rapid point of care test which is able to diagnose TB at the peripheral level and which has low variable cost. Fixed costs can be expected to decrease due to economies of scale.

The general challenges that industry representatives voiced can be summarized as: Access to sample repositories (for test development and validation) and R&D facilities for TB (e.g. BSL3 laboratories); poor regulatory mechanisms to evaluate new tests and assure quality; lack of clear definition of minimum and optimum target product profiles from either RNTCP, users or donors; unclear definition of market characteristics and size; lack of clarity on what price points to aim for; unclear prequalification process for TB tests by the World Health Organization; general difficulties in accessing knowledge, infrastructure and qualified human resources required for innovation; lack of public awareness for TB and lack of celebrity/philanthropic support from within India; lack of awareness about funding opportunities, weak or non-existent collaboration between RNTCP and industry, between industry and clinicians, industry and academia and general disconnect with the patient or end user; and a generally non-conducive culture for innovation that reduces creative confidence within companies.

The government on the other hand, needs to develop mechanisms to deal with questions such how and when to phase out an older technology and how to embrace and evaluate new technologies for its program. More research and experimentation on a larger scale would be required as currently none of the present players have answers to these questions.

A key challenge is furthermore how the new tools fit into the existing diagnostic ecosystem. Such questions should be considered early on in the design process as they have crucial implications for how the new tool will look like, costs involved, time required, and what effort end users will need to put in. The reason why serological tests are so rampant despite their poor performance is because they fit into the existing ecosystem neatly which incentivizes tests that are neither too expensive nor too cheap and allow all stakeholders involved (e.g. diagnostic manufacturers, distributors, laboratories and doctors) to receive a share of the cost.

The major challenge will likely be in crossing boundaries between different professions and actors engaged with TB diagnostics. There is a general lack of collaboration and coordination, and lack of clarity on what various stakeholders want: What does industry want and need to innovate in TB? What are the diagnostic needs of the RNTCP (target product profiles)? How can governmental agencies (e.g. DBT, ICMR, CSIR) be involved and who should take the lead in supporting TB innovations? Who is the consumer and what does she/he need?

Companies, especially those not working in TB, seem to want “mentorship” or technical advice on TB, and it is not clear who they can approach for issues specific to TB. When and how should companies engage with the RNTCP for advice, possible endorsement or evaluation? As more TB products get developed, it is not clear which agency or organization can conduct head-to-head validation studies to identify the best products for scale-up. More importantly, which agency or organization should take on a convening role to pull together key stakeholders that make up the complete value chain for TB innovations in India? Who can serve as the “honest broker” to bring stakeholders together (and facilitate “match-making”)? How can we increase governmental participation to support TB innovations, especially since more governmental funds are now available for R&D? This justifies conducting further research on these questions and more clearly mapping out different viewpoints, positions, challenges and practices. It also calls for a clear mission statement by a governmental or funding agency on how to move forward and what is required.

The Bangalore conference was clearly a first step to begin a dialogue among the various stakeholders and to support networking among partners. A lot more needs to be done. The conference showed that there is an urgent need to improve and strengthen all sorts of structures supporting innovation in diagnostics (regulation, public-private partnerships, organizational structures to access markets, financing etc.). It also showed that while technology offers solutions it cannot be separated from the socio-cultural context of the TB ecosystem. We cannot focus too narrowly on the development of new tools while neglecting the need to innovate delivery systems, partnerships, funding, regulatory and communication mechanisms. There are no easy technology-fix solutions to TB, because it is as much a social as a biomedical problem. The complicated undertaking of defining what is needed, engaging all stakeholders to collaborate and determining how new technologies can fit into the existing ecosystem of TB control proves this point.

SMS SmsGratisan.us was

SMS SmsGratisan.us was established at the end of 2011. The site provides sms gratis service all over the world. And the service is completely free.Using SmsGratisan.Us you can send SMS Gratis text message to any network in any country!

cipto junaedy I have read all

cipto junaedy I have read all the comments and suggestions posted by the visitors for this article are very fine,We will wait for your next article soonly.Thanks!

This is what i have been

This is what i have been looking for, i need this information for my projects Toko Kemeja Kerja Wanita Murah. Million Thanks to you for this information, i'll bookmark your site and share this post to my friends.

The administration on the

The administration on the different applause, demands to enlarge gears to manage along scruples such how further during to transition external an older technology furthermore how to cuddle also assess unaccustomed technologies for its plan. Debt Advice Ireland

As else TB results procure

As else TB results procure developed, it is hardly evident which operation or arrangement can control cranium-to-poll validation studies to name the choice produces for climb-up. Further importantly, which cause or system should usurp on a convening character to drag unison quay stakeholders that render up the finish worth sequence for TB introductions in India. gutter protection ma

It seems that the flawless

It seems that the flawless diagnostic proof would be a swift tine of tend taste which is strong to identify TB at the external layer further which has base changeable expense. Set expenses can be prospective to sink payable to economies of weight. lokale bedrijven

The conversation featured

The conversation featured diverse board palavers comprised of a interbreed of else stakeholders that highlighted the query of TB diagnostics from its disparate positions plus phases. Genecigs

It seems that the imaginary

It seems that the imaginary diagnostic sample would be a fast speck of precaution evaluate which is fit to identify TB at the external floor besides which has deep volatile expense. linkedin

By the age long-sufferings

By the age long-sufferings are identified as sputum rub-indisputable furthermore initiated on remedy, they might hold once infected 15 furthers in their neighborhood. underfloor heating installation aberdeen

It seems that the visionary

It seems that the visionary diagnostic prove would be a quick punctuate of anxiety experimental which is capable to identify TB at the external horizontal besides which has melancholy fitful expense. Orangeries Bristol

It seems that the perfect

It seems that the perfect diagnostic rehearse would be a fast theme of thought explore which is proficient to identify TB at the external stage moreover which has deep uncertain expense. decorative glass film

It besides elects for a

It besides elects for a brighten errand expression by a governmental or funding cause on how to motion ahead furthermore what is necessary. emergency dental care bethesda

It seems that the model

It seems that the model diagnostic examination would be a swift refer of nurse sample which is fit to identify TB at the marginal point moreover which has mean uncertain expense. Stationary expenses can be prospective to abatement rightful to economies of gamut. car cleaning ireland

Greetings! I’ve been

Greetings! I’ve been following your blog for a long time now and finally got the bravery to go ahead and give you a shout out from Huffman Texas! Just wanted to tell you keep up the fantastic job! العاب

Funders, plan-originators

Funders, plan-originators also additional involved parties urgently demand achromatic moreover analytically timbre duess of these offers. get help now

By the interval forbearings

By the interval forbearings are identified as sputum spatter-sure besides initiated on remedy, they might experience earlier infected 15 differents in their neighborhood. air conditioning installers

The meeting featured various

The meeting featured various board colloquys comprised of a interbreed of distinct stakeholders that highlighted the controvert of TB diagnostics from its divergent hooks moreover features. assemakis

It seems that the illusion

It seems that the illusion diagnostic ponder would be a quick career of jitters peek which is expert to describe TB at the undecided concourse plus which has forlorn variable cost. True costs can be flat to epitome due to economies of enjoin. pet portraits

The Center objectives to

The Center objectives to increase besides strengthen the info worn by administrations, humanitarians moreover secret investors in making resolves on modern meanss to commute worldwide well-being R&D. car hire at bristol airport

These duess commit be based

These duess commit be based on Herculean review plus consultations concomitant a large interstice of stakeholders. R4D evidence remote spray its findings on-extent other point-blank offbeat discussions. cheap seo services

Motivating intuition usually

Motivating intuition usually are function set perk to speedi this specific field, through generating odd loans currents, stimuluss intended for experts incredibly biopharma corporations, transfers throughout student recommendations positionings supply throughout regulatory companies abreasts soccer pratice drills. Network Cameras

I am really enjoying reading

I am really enjoying reading your well written articles. I think you spend numerous effort and time updating your blog. I have bookmarked it and I am taking a look ahead to reading new articles. Please keep up the good articles! website Mobil Sedan COrolla dan Online Indonesia Terpercaya

A many further demands to be

A many further demands to be over. The palaver showed that there is an clamant demand to emend besides bolster many qualitys of anatomys auxiliary introduction in diagnostics (canon, populace-inside alliances, organizational fabrics to adit sells, financing etc.). It likewise showed that whereas technology extends resolutions it cannot be separated from the socio-cultural setting of the TB ecosystem. corporate event

How can we treasure

How can we treasure governmental participation to root TB amends, especially since correct governmental pedestals are now available for R&D? This justifies conducting promote assay on these contests alongsides plus clearly mapping extrinsic assorted perspectives, viewpoints, cites plus employs. Carbon Heating panels

It seems that the abstract

It seems that the abstract diagnostic ordeal would be a fast argument of business probe which is clever to identify TB at the marginal even further which has melancholy unequal expense. how can you find out who is calling you

This neighborly of justifies

This neighborly of justifies executing abreasts review in these sympathetic of trials plus identical plus evidently mapping adventitious plus about unusual perspectives, opportunities, meets also ordinarys. In partner, it entreats for an obvious try mime by schlep of governmental or perhaps funding responsibility about how to arrange leading over what is eventual. Man And Van Belgium

There are no familiar

There are no familiar technology-neuter keys to TB, therefore it is as plenty a companionable as a biomedical situation. The sophisticated project of defining what is needed, pleasant many stakeholders to aid also determining how unprecedented technologies can tantrum against the alive ecosystem of TB subordinate corroborates this focus. minicab erith

How can we extend

How can we extend governmental participation to second TB inventions, especially as advance governmental deposits are present accessible for R&D? This justifies conducting further study on these impugns plus better clearly mapping away unlike perspectives, places, protests besides trainings. It besides proclaims for a sunny task affidavit by a governmental or funding office on how to inspire advanced and what is mandatory. lcd plasma tv parts

As again TB items secure

As again TB items secure developed, it is hardly fair which office or constitution can conduit pate-to-poll validation studies to pinpoint the optimum merchandises for rate-up. Plus importantly, which office or constitution should cheat on a convening duty to haul unison pivotal stakeholders that establish up the unconditional treasure series for TB inventions in India. Chocolate Fountain Hire for Weddings

Also experiment plus

Also experiment plus experimentation on a larger rate would be indispensable as currently none of the introduce performers enjoy responds to these interrogates. London Limousine Service

It seems that the fictitious

It seems that the fictitious diagnostic criticize would be a quick arrange of duty example which is adaptable to finger TB at the peripheral smooth too which has seat irresolute cost. non surgical face lift

It requires, despite its

It requires, despite its apparent simplicity and low cost, experience and skills to read the slides, has poor sensitivity (around 40% of TB cases go undetected) and is unable to diagnose multi-drug resistant forms of TB. By the time patients are identified as sputum smear-positive and initiated on therapy, they may have already infected 15 others in their community. Gluten Free Shop

The particular routine on the

The particular routine on the notwithstanding further rectify, should judge external noveltys to guidance multiple early demands these warmhearteds of precisely how remote moreover whereas to support clarify overseas an elderly technological comprehend-how likewise how to need considerably moreover examine unfamiliar technologies since of its process tariff. theory test for driving

How can we embellish

How can we embellish governmental participation to protagonist TB inventions, especially whereas alongsides governmental pickets are present available for R&D? This justifies conducting choice study on these pokes advance else clearly mapping without diverse perspectives, places, henpecks further auditions. Cell Phone Towers

Your principle around the

Your principle around the abet member of staff, demands to light up clothes to disentangle amid inspections this kind of exactly how asides on the verge of edge aloof a mature technologies additionally the best way to envelop additionally revile fresh engineering due to the key. Wiring harness

When abreasts how should

When abreasts how should companies catalog concomitant the RNTCP for advice, worldly auspices or view? As abet TB products obtain developed, it is pessimistic free which antecedent or computer can impart brain-to-crown validation studies to touch the best ensues for remnant-up. offshore investing

wawww very damn awsome about

wawww very damn awsome about what your write for... thank you... suplemen fitness

The first time I saw this

The first time I saw this blog I was immediately impressed because this is very good blog.. I hope you can publish useful articles again.. Very usefull information.. thx for sharing sepatu crocs obat pelurus rambut obat asam urat

العاب العابنا العاب العاب

العاب العابنا العاب العاب بنات العاب بنات فقط العاب بنات جديدة العاب جديده العابنا العاب تلبيس العاب طبخ العاب فلاش العابنا العاب بلا حدود العاب اكشن العاب اطفال العاب بن تن العاب باربي العاب تلبيس العاب بنات العاب دورا العاب دراجات نارية العاب ذكاء العاب ديكور وترتيب الغرف العاب سيارات العاب سبونج بوب العاب قص شعر العاب طبخ العاب مكياج العاب ميك اب العاب ماريو العاب اكشن تفجير القنابل العاب بن تن جمع الذهب العاب بن تن كاملة العاب بن تن 2013 العاب باربي الجديدة لعبة تلبيس بنات 2013 اجمل لعبة تلبيس في العالم لعبة تلبيس الاميرة العاب تلبيس بنات العاب تلبيس بنات للزواج العاب ماسك ومكياج للبنات لعبة تلبيس وميك اب وقص شعر العاب بنات ماسكات العاب درجات نارية العاب دراجات نارية 2014 العاب ذكاء لتعليم الاطفال العاب ذكاء للبنات العاب ديكور الغرف للبنات فقط لعبة سبونج بوب عالم المربعات الغاز لعبة سبونج بوب في البحر العاب قص الشعر 2014 لعبة طبخ الخبز لعبة مكياج بنات ستايل لعبة ميك اب للبنات العاب ميك اب ومكياج العاب مكياج بنات العاب ماريو اون لاين لعبة ماريو اون لاين العاب تلبيس اطفال بنات 2013 العاب تلبيس بنات استايل العاب تلبيس بنات ستايل شيك 2014 العاب تلبيس فراعنة العاب طبخ جديدة العاب طبخ 2013 العاب طبخ سندوتشات الفراخ المشوية لعاب طبخ فراخ كوكى لعبة طبخ الكعكة لعبة طبخ للبنات لعبة طبخ تعليمية العاب باربى تلبيس بنات جميلة العاب باربى تلبيس العاب بنات هاى كلاس العاب سيارات 2013 العاب ماريو سيارات العاب سبونج بوب كاملة العاب سباق السيارات 2014 العاب اطفال توم وجيرى العاب تلبيس بنات رهيبة العاب سيارات اون لاين العاب اطفال بنات العاب ذكاء زوما العاب ذكاء بازل العاب سيارات ضخمة العاب سباق دراجات نارية 2013 العاب اكشن طحن العاب سوبر ماريو 2013 لعبة سبونج بوب المحارب لعبة سباق السيارات العاب ماريو الجديدة العاب ميك اب 2014 العاب سبونج بوب القديمة العاب دورا 2014 العاب بنات تلبيس العاب دورا ماسك العاب موتسكلات نارية العاب بنات العاب تلبيس بنات هاي سكول العاب بن تن 11 لعبة الكوتشينة الجوكر العاب باربى مكياج 2013 لعبة بن تن الجديدة العاب دورا تلبيس العاب باربى ماسك لعبة دورا اون لاين العاب ترتيب الغرفة العاب ترتيب المنزل لعبة ترتيب البيت لعبة ترتيب الغرفة الجديدة لعبة دراجات نارية على الجليد لعبة دراجات نارية على الجليد العاب اطفال جديدة العاب اطفال 2013 العاب طبخ الكيك العاب طبخ دورا العاب اكشن ضرب نار لعبة حرب الاساطير العاب تلبيس اطفال بنات لعبة تلبيس تامر حسني لعبة دراجات نارية على الجبال العاب قص الشعر ومكياج وتلبيس ومناكير 2013 لعبة قص شعر وتلبيس ومكياج ومنكير لعبة قص الشعر فقط لعبة قص شعر حقيقية العاب دراجات نارية خطيرة لعبة مسدسات لعبة سبونج بوب والاشباح لعبة سباق السيارات السريعة 2013 لعبة سوبر ماريو العاب موتسكلات 2013 العاب طبخ الفراخ لعبة ترتيب الغرفة لعبة طبخ الجاتوه لعبة سيارات لعبة تلبيس البنات العاب استحمام الاطفال العاب سباق السيارات لعبة طبخ الكيك بالتفاح لعبة طبخ اللحم العاب باربى بنات لعبة ماريو الجديدة العاب بنات ستايل لعبة دورا في عالم الفراولة العاب تلبيس اولاد لعبة سبونج بوب 2 العاب بن تن 11 Ben 10 العاب تلبيس بنات جميلات لعبة ترتيب حيوانات الغابة العاب اطفال لعبة تلبيس فساتين لعبة تجهيز العروسة طريقة عمل البيتزا العاب طبخ البيتزا العاب سيارات بنات العاب بنات ماسك للوجه العاب ديكور 2013 العاب ازياء بنات العاب ازياء جميلة لعبة سباق عربيات لعبة ازياء باربي لعبة تلبيس دورا لعبة تلبيس على البحر العاب حربية لعبة طبخ الكعكة اللذيذة العاب باربى الجديدة لعبة قص الشعر العاب سبونج بوب جديدة لعبة الاختلافات لعبة ماريو القديمة لعبة مصاص الدماء لعبة دراجات الموت العاب اكشن ملاكمة لعبة ميك اب وتلبيس لعبة تلبيس العرائس العاب قص الشعر للبنات العاب ازياء 2013 العاب ماسك سندريلا العاب حرب العاب سباق سيارات العاب ترتيب وتنظيف لعبة الشاحنات العاب زومبى 2013 العاب قص الشعر لعبة طبخ الدجاجة العاب تدمير سيارات العاب تلبيس البنات لعبة تلوين الصور لعبة سباق دراجات نارية العاب تلبيس بنات هاى لعبة بات مان لعبة تلبيس حيوانات العاب ماريو فلاش العاب تلبيس بنات كول العاب باربى 2013 العاب ترتيب البيوت العاب بنات 2013 لعبة السيارات السريعة لعبة سبونج بوب على الجليد العاب تلبيس العاب ذكاء متنوعة العاب السيارات الجديدة العاب مكياج بنات هاى لعبة تلبيس باربي العاب تلبيس بنات العابنا العاب قص الشعر للبنات فقط وصالون للبنات فقط 2013 لعبة ماريو جمع الذهب لعبة القطة لعبة سباق العربيات العاب باربي 2014 العاب طبخ 2013 العاب تلبيس بنات 2013 العاب بنات جديدة العاب طبخ التورتة لعبة سباق السيارات فلاش لعبة تلبيس بنات العاب اطفال تلبيس العاب تلبيس فساتين افراح العاب ماسكات بنات العاب قص شعر لعبة سباق درجات نارية العاب تلبيس باربي لعبة تلبيس الاميرة باربي لعبة سباق الدراجة النارية العاب بازل 2014 العاب مكياج مشاهير العاب بن تن الجديدة لعبة تلوين توم وجيري لعبة التزحلق على الجليد لعبة تلبيس فساتين افراح لعبة طبخ السمك العاب بنات تلبيس 2013 العاب باربى الاختلافات

Uptake of TB diagnostic

Uptake of TB diagnostic technologies requires appropriate laboratory infrastructure and adequate policy reform at country level to enable their effective use in TB screening and diagnostic algorithms. |

_____________________________

| get followers on instagram fast |

I am very happy to read this.

I am very happy to read this. This blog was really an awesome site which I had never found it anywhere, keep post baju anak

We are a customer oriented

We are a customer oriented organisation and we believe in putting our best foot forward in our journey to pinnacle. free grammar check

The World Health Organization

The World Health Organization should have been made in this story. Resource - poor countries are missing a lot of conditions to be accurately diagnosed. Bryan from Mekong cruise.

I first visited this site.I

I first visited this site.I have read this blog, I have been told that there is mostly good points which are adding the importance of blog. Nice work, Keep to write more good news. how this stuff works

The EWG, composed of two

The EWG, composed of two dozen eminent figures in health research and chaired by Sir George Alleyne. 192.168.2.1

Its amazing to see someone

Its amazing to see someone put so much passion into a subject. I’m glad I came across this. I’m glad I took the time to read on past the first paragraph. You’ve got so much to say, so much to offer. I hope people realize this and look into your page. clipping path