Center for Global Health R&D Policy Assessment

Follow us on:

WHO Expert Group supports binding convention on health R&D for developing countries

An Interview with Judit Rius Sanjuan, US Manager of the Access Campaign of Médecins Sans Frontières\Doctors Without Borders (MSF)

Recently, the World Health Organization (WHO) Consultative Expert Working Group on Research and Development: Financing and Coordination (CEWG) released its final report Research and Development to Meet Health Needs in Developing Countries: Strengthening Global Financing and Coordination.

Soma Ghoshal interviewed Judit Rius Sanjuan, US Manager of the Access Campaign of Médecins Sans Frontières\Doctors Without Borders (MSF) to find out more about the origins, significance, and likely impact of the CEWG’s work.

1. Many of our readers may not be familiar with the history of this topic within the WHO. Can you describe the origin and objectives of the CEWG?

Many Member States, as well as civil society and experts, have long recognized that the current system for health research and development (R&D) do not adequately address the needs of developing countries, and as a result, they have supported a series of initiatives to investigate and find solutions to correct this imbalance, culminating in the creation of the WHO Consultative Expert Working Group on Research and Development: Financing and Coordination (CEWG) in 2010, which report was just released.

The CEWG was concretely tasked with examining “current financing and coordination of research and development, as well as proposals for new and innovative sources of financing to stimulate research and development related to the needs of developing countries.”

The CEWG report begins with an important paragraph that sets the stage for their work quite clearly:

“The issue we were asked to investigate was identified at least two decades ago. Market mechanisms, and also publicly-funded research, collectively result in far too little investment in research and development on diseases that mainly affect developing countries. This means that poor people suffer and die because there are no effective health technologies like medicines, vaccines or diagnostics. Markets fail because intellectual property rights are not an effective incentive in these circumstances, and public investment is also dominated by the rich world and its own health needs. This is the challenge for the world as a whole, which has guided our discussions and deliberations. We have framed our recommendations to indicate that finding solutions is the responsibility of all of us in this interdependent world, in developed and developing countries alike.”

The experts considered a number of proposals for specific mechanisms to address R&D gaps for the developing world submitted by Member States, academics, industry and civil society, including a joint submission by MSF, Health Action International Global, Initiative for Health & Equity in Society, Knowledge Ecology International, and Third World Network entitled “Consideration of an Essential Health and Biomedical R&D Treaty.”

The CEWG process was also informed by two previous and very important WHO documents: the 2006 report of the Commission on Intellectual Property Rights, Innovation and Public Health (CIPIH Report), which concluded that the current innovation system has failed patients in developing countries, and the 2008 WHO Global Strategy and Plan of Action on Public Health, Innovation and Intellectual Property, that provided a roadmap on how to ensure innovation and access to medical technologies highly negotiated by WHO Member States.

While the CEWG’s report contains a series of recommendations, arguably the most striking recommendation is for WHO Member States to start negotiations on a new, binding, global R&D convention. The CEWG report argues that a binding convention “is needed to secure appropriate funding and coordination to promote R&D needed to address the diseases that disproportionately affect developing countries and which constitute a common global responsibility.”

2. In your opinion, what is the overall significance of the CEWG’s recommendations?

MSF considers the recommendation for a binding R&D treaty to be a landmark development in global health. The CEWG’s recommendations have the potential to boost R&D focused on the needs of patients living in developing countries, but also to change the way R&D is conducted to ensure that patients have affordable access to the fruits of innovations.

While efforts in recent years to address gaps in R&D have delivered some urgently needed innovations for resource-poor environments, these ad hoc efforts are not part of a sustainable system and are inadequate to meet the health needs in developing countries.
The CEWG’s comprehensive proposal takes us beyond the current piecemeal approach towards a more cohesive solution for priority-setting, funding and coordination based on global health needs. A binding convention could be a game changer in building a sustainable system to develop and deliver urgently needed vaccines, diagnostics and drugs to patients in the developing world.

The report contains an excellent analysis of the failures of the current R&D system for the developing countries where we work. It also assesses a variety of proposed R&D financing, coordination and incentive mechanisms according to their potential public health impact, as well as their technical and financial feasibility.

The report further concludes that removing the link between the cost of R&D and the price of medicines should be a fundamental principle underpinning approaches to R&D for developing countries to ensure that resulting medical technologies will be affordable. In addition, the report specifies that an absolutely necessary condition for implementing these approaches will be a sustainable source of funding.

3. What are some of the implications of the recommendations for current R&D donors and other countries?

The recommendations could be transformative for R&D donors in several ways. The CEWG proposes the creation of new global norms for financing and coordinating priority medical R&D. It also aims to promote a more sustainable system for medical innovation to address the needs of patients in developing countries, based on the fair and equitable sharing of costs, access to benefits of R&D, and incentives to invest in needs-driven innovation.

Regarding overall funding of R&D by governments, the CEWG report’s principal conclusion is that all countries (developed and developing) should commit to spend at least 0.01% of GDP on government-funded R&D devoted to meeting the health needs of developing countries. In addition, the CEWG report proposes that countries should consider these targets:

• Developing countries with a potential research capacity should aim to commit 0.05−0.1% of GDP to government-funded health research of all kinds
• Developed countries should aim to commit 0.15−0.2% of GDP to government funded health research of all kinds

The global convention could be useful for donors who currently make important contributions to global health R&D, especially in terms of prioritizing and coordinating efforts in relation to global health needs, but will also hopefully serve as a catalyst for countries that should be committing more.

Independently from the WHO discussion, I hope the report and its recommendations start a process of rethinking the way innovation is financed and coordinated at the national and regional levels. The result will hopefully be increased R&D financing and coordination for developing countries, and better models for biomedical innovation that promote both innovation and access.

4. MSF and others often use a term called “de-linkage” when they talk about the principles that they believe should govern the global innovation system. Could you explain the basic concept of de-linkage and give a few examples of how this principle could be successfully applied in practice?

One of the main problems with the current innovation model is that it relies on high prices, made possible with tools like patent-protected monopolies, to recover R&D costs. This model has at least two major flaws: a) high prices leave millions of patients without access to medicines that they cannot afford; b) a lack of incentives to drive innovation for patients (or governments that pay for their treatment) who cannot pay high-prices or create a profitable market. The system encourages profit-driven, rather than needs-driven, R&D, leaving many patient needs unaddressed.

Therefore, MSF advocates for an innovation system that de-links, or separates, the R&D cost from the sales price of products, therefore ensuring both innovation and access, and re-directing R&D efforts towards a more patients needs-driven approach.

Breaking the link between R&D costs and the sales price of products can be accomplished through a variety of incentive mechanisms, and should be seen as a standard for evaluating how well incentive mechanisms do against public health objectives. For example, the concept of de-linkage could serve as a way to assess incentive mechanisms currently being explored, including Innovation Inducement Prizes, Advance Market Commitments, the US FDA Priority Review Voucher, and the new USPTO Patents for Humanity pilot.

The WHO Member States have already recognized that separating the costs of R&D from the sales price of products is an important issue that should be further explored, and one of the main conclusions of the 2008 WHO Global Strategy and Plan of Action was a mandate “to explore, and, where appropriate, promote a range of incentive schemes for research and developing including addressing, where appropriate, the de-linkage of the costs of research and development and the price of health products, for example through the award of prizes, with the objective of addressing diseases which disproportionately affect developing countries.”

In its final report, the CEWG agrees that de-linkage is a powerful principle. It mentions some examples where de-linkage has been or could be applied, such as open innovation models where the R&D costs are covered by public or philanthropic sources and research results are made available in the public domain; licensing conditions imposed by funders or research organizations that permit non-exclusive licensing or prescribe a low target price for a product; or more comprehensive schemes that envision wholesale replacement of the intellectual property system by government-funded payments for R&D. MSF is especially interested in innovation inducement prizes as one way to separate the cost of innovation from the final price of products. During the negotiation of the WHO Global Strategy, the governments of Barbados, Bolivia, Suriname, and Bangladesh presented several proposals for prizes to reward innovation, including two proposals that MSF has followed with particular interest, given the diseases that we currently treat: a Chagas disease prize fund for the development of new treatments, diagnostics and vaccines; and a prize fund for development of low-cost rapid diagnostic test for tuberculosis.

In May 2012, the 65th World Health Assembly will deliberate over the findings and recommendations of the CEWG. The key to translating the CEWG recommendations into action will, of course, be political will and leadership by the WHO and its Member States. MSF hopes that governments will seize this opportunity and commit to starting the process of establishing a binding convention on research and development relevant to the health needs of developing countries.

Development must be meet

Development must be meet towards the health all the need which require the patients so NGO's also take the necessary action in order to get the better results in this regard. Healthcare practice management

cipto junaedy I have read all

cipto junaedy I have read all the comments and suggestions posted by the visitors for this article are very fine,We will wait for your next article soonly.Thanks!

It requires, regardless its

It requires, regardless its conspicuous simplicity further vile expense, feeling furthermore abilitys to show the chutes, has lean sensitivity (almost 40% of TB cases go unnoticed) further is helpless to identify multi-sedative immune rituals of TB. Alfamart official partner merchandise FIFA piala dunia Brazil 2014
Agen Texas Online Indonesia Terpercaya
http://etnisjawa.blogspot.com/2014/01/agen-texas-online-indonesia-terpercaya.html

How awesome article!This is a

How awesome article!This is a difficult project, I'm glad you will work so hard do something you love, I am now also actively working to make a living in order to buy more dvd Mobil Sedan COrolla dan Agen Online Indonesia Terpercaya

It was really depressing for

It was really depressing for me to lose my trust on charities just because of american cancer society scam but now I feel myself blessed to be known to an institute like Breast Cancer Society. It is a society of hardworking and honest people with full conviction to work for eliminating breast cancer from the society.

Candor Recruitment Group is

Candor Recruitment Group is the best recruitment agency in Pakistan due to his work. Recruiter Staffing We do best to find job for our clients and our clients are satisfied with our service. Candor Recruitment Group is one of the topper companies because we are always ready to support our clients; Recruitment Business in Dubai we are the World's Best Recruitment Agency in Pakistan. Staffing Services Manpower Recruitment Business Management Outsourcing Group combining unparalleled experience, comprehensive capabilities across all industries and business functions, Latest jobs in Pakistan and Gulf and extensive research on the world's most successful companies, Source of Manpower in Pakistan and Gulf Candor Recruitment Group collaborates with clients to help them to become high-performance Businesses man and govern the Industries.

Compaq International is

Compaq International is committed to provide the highest quality power cable accessories. The company with it's ShrinkFit trademark stands leader in India and overseas market.
Cable accessories suppliers
Lightning arrester
Heat shrinkable single core cables
Heat shrinkable jointing kits
Cold shrink outdoor cable
Cold shrink indoor termination kits

Green Power International was

Green Power International was established in early 2002 in close cooperation with MWM GmbH (formerly Deutz Power System GmbH).
Genset manufacturers
Natural gas genset
Landfill gas

العاب العابنا العاب العاب

العاب العابنا العاب العاب بنات العاب بنات فقط العاب بنات جديدة العاب جديده العابنا العاب تلبيس العاب طبخ العاب فلاش العابنا العاب بلا حدود العاب اكشن العاب اطفال العاب بن تن العاب باربي العاب تلبيس العاب بنات العاب دورا العاب دراجات نارية العاب ذكاء العاب ديكور وترتيب الغرف العاب سيارات العاب سبونج بوب العاب قص شعر العاب طبخ العاب مكياج العاب ميك اب العاب ماريو العاب اكشن تفجير القنابل العاب بن تن جمع الذهب العاب بن تن كاملة العاب بن تن 2013 العاب باربي الجديدة لعبة تلبيس بنات 2013 اجمل لعبة تلبيس في العالم لعبة تلبيس الاميرة العاب تلبيس بنات العاب تلبيس بنات للزواج العاب ماسك ومكياج للبنات لعبة تلبيس وميك اب وقص شعر العاب بنات ماسكات العاب درجات نارية العاب دراجات نارية 2014 العاب ذكاء لتعليم الاطفال العاب ذكاء للبنات العاب ديكور الغرف للبنات فقط لعبة سبونج بوب عالم المربعات الغاز لعبة سبونج بوب في البحر العاب قص الشعر 2014 لعبة طبخ الخبز لعبة مكياج بنات ستايل لعبة ميك اب للبنات العاب ميك اب ومكياج العاب مكياج بنات العاب ماريو اون لاين لعبة ماريو اون لاين العاب تلبيس اطفال بنات 2013 العاب تلبيس بنات استايل العاب تلبيس بنات ستايل شيك 2014 العاب تلبيس فراعنة العاب طبخ جديدة العاب طبخ 2013 العاب طبخ سندوتشات الفراخ المشوية لعاب طبخ فراخ كوكى لعبة طبخ الكعكة لعبة طبخ للبنات لعبة طبخ تعليمية العاب باربى تلبيس بنات جميلة العاب باربى تلبيس العاب بنات هاى كلاس العاب سيارات 2013 العاب ماريو سيارات العاب سبونج بوب كاملة العاب سباق السيارات 2014 العاب اطفال توم وجيرى العاب تلبيس بنات رهيبة العاب سيارات اون لاين العاب اطفال بنات العاب ذكاء زوما العاب ذكاء بازل العاب سيارات ضخمة العاب سباق دراجات نارية 2013 العاب اكشن طحن العاب سوبر ماريو 2013 لعبة سبونج بوب المحارب لعبة سباق السيارات العاب ماريو الجديدة العاب ميك اب 2014 العاب سبونج بوب القديمة العاب دورا 2014 العاب بنات تلبيس العاب دورا ماسك العاب موتسكلات نارية العاب بنات العاب تلبيس بنات هاي سكول العاب بن تن 11 لعبة الكوتشينة الجوكر العاب باربى مكياج 2013 لعبة بن تن الجديدة العاب دورا تلبيس العاب باربى ماسك لعبة دورا اون لاين العاب ترتيب الغرفة العاب ترتيب المنزل لعبة ترتيب البيت لعبة ترتيب الغرفة الجديدة لعبة دراجات نارية على الجليد لعبة دراجات نارية على الجليد العاب اطفال جديدة العاب اطفال 2013 العاب طبخ الكيك العاب طبخ دورا العاب اكشن ضرب نار لعبة حرب الاساطير العاب تلبيس اطفال بنات لعبة تلبيس تامر حسني لعبة دراجات نارية على الجبال العاب قص الشعر ومكياج وتلبيس ومناكير 2013 لعبة قص شعر وتلبيس ومكياج ومنكير لعبة قص الشعر فقط لعبة قص شعر حقيقية العاب دراجات نارية خطيرة لعبة مسدسات لعبة سبونج بوب والاشباح لعبة سباق السيارات السريعة 2013 لعبة سوبر ماريو العاب موتسكلات 2013 العاب طبخ الفراخ لعبة ترتيب الغرفة لعبة طبخ الجاتوه لعبة سيارات لعبة تلبيس البنات العاب استحمام الاطفال العاب سباق السيارات لعبة طبخ الكيك بالتفاح لعبة طبخ اللحم العاب باربى بنات لعبة ماريو الجديدة العاب بنات ستايل لعبة دورا في عالم الفراولة العاب تلبيس اولاد لعبة سبونج بوب 2 العاب بن تن 11 Ben 10 العاب تلبيس بنات جميلات لعبة ترتيب حيوانات الغابة العاب اطفال لعبة تلبيس فساتين لعبة تجهيز العروسة طريقة عمل البيتزا العاب طبخ البيتزا العاب سيارات بنات العاب بنات ماسك للوجه العاب ديكور 2013 العاب ازياء بنات العاب ازياء جميلة لعبة سباق عربيات لعبة ازياء باربي لعبة تلبيس دورا لعبة تلبيس على البحر العاب حربية لعبة طبخ الكعكة اللذيذة العاب باربى الجديدة لعبة قص الشعر العاب سبونج بوب جديدة لعبة الاختلافات لعبة ماريو القديمة لعبة مصاص الدماء لعبة دراجات الموت العاب اكشن ملاكمة لعبة ميك اب وتلبيس لعبة تلبيس العرائس العاب قص الشعر للبنات العاب ازياء 2013 العاب ماسك سندريلا العاب حرب العاب سباق سيارات العاب ترتيب وتنظيف لعبة الشاحنات العاب زومبى 2013 العاب قص الشعر لعبة طبخ الدجاجة العاب تدمير سيارات العاب تلبيس البنات لعبة تلوين الصور لعبة سباق دراجات نارية العاب تلبيس بنات هاى لعبة بات مان لعبة تلبيس حيوانات العاب ماريو فلاش العاب تلبيس بنات كول العاب باربى 2013 العاب ترتيب البيوت العاب بنات 2013 لعبة السيارات السريعة لعبة سبونج بوب على الجليد العاب تلبيس العاب ذكاء متنوعة العاب السيارات الجديدة العاب مكياج بنات هاى لعبة تلبيس باربي العاب تلبيس بنات العابنا العاب قص الشعر للبنات فقط وصالون للبنات فقط 2013 لعبة ماريو جمع الذهب لعبة القطة لعبة سباق العربيات العاب باربي 2014 العاب طبخ 2013 العاب تلبيس بنات 2013 العاب بنات جديدة العاب طبخ التورتة لعبة سباق السيارات فلاش لعبة تلبيس بنات العاب اطفال تلبيس العاب تلبيس فساتين افراح العاب ماسكات بنات العاب قص شعر لعبة سباق درجات نارية العاب تلبيس باربي لعبة تلبيس الاميرة باربي لعبة سباق الدراجة النارية العاب بازل 2014 العاب مكياج مشاهير العاب بن تن الجديدة لعبة تلوين توم وجيري لعبة التزحلق على الجليد لعبة تلبيس فساتين افراح لعبة طبخ السمك العاب بنات تلبيس 2013 العاب باربى الاختلافات

This is the eighth in a

This is the eighth in a series of interviews by Hassan Masum of leaders of collaborative health R&D programs. 192.168.2.1

The CEWG was concretely

The CEWG was concretely tasked with examining “current financing and coordination of research and development, as well as proposals for new and innovative sources of financing to stimulate research and development related to the needs of developing countries.”

SEO Services Company

MSF considers the

MSF considers the recommendation for a binding R&D treaty to be a landmark development in global health. The CEWG’s recommendations have the potential to boost R&D focused on the needs of patients living in developing countries, but also to change the way R&D is conducted to ensure that patients have affordable access to the fruits of innovations.

SEO Services Company

The CEWG was concretely

The CEWG was concretely tasked with examining “current financing and coordination of research and development, as well as proposals for new and innovative sources of financing to stimulate research and development related to the needs of developing countries.”

Blog Commenting Service

I am very happy to read this

I am very happy to read this article. It is my great honor. I gathered useful information on this point as I am working on a business project. Thank you posting relative information and its now becoming easier to complete this assignment. Downton Abbey Seasons 1-3 DVD Box Set | Two and a Half Men Seasons 1-10 DVD Box Set | Cold Case Seasons 1-7 DVD Box Set

I like this article. I think

I like this article. I think it writes very well. Your post contains useful information on this point as I am working on a college project. Thank you posting relative information and its now becoming easier to complete this topic. Psych Seasons 1-6 DVD Box Set | Game of Thrones Season 3 DVD Box Set | Breaking Bad Season 5 DVD Box Set

This article is also very

This article is also very useful. There are many important informations in this article. I must say I am very impressed with the way you and your site effectively messages are very informative. You really captured the attention of many, apparently, go! Supernatural Seasons 1-8 DVD Box Set | NCIS Seasons 1-10 DVD Box Set | Criminal Minds 1-8 Season DVD Box Set

Good text. Thanks you

Good text. Thanks you Malarnia proszkowa Poznan Welcome you Blog motoryzacyjny find some and.

How awesome article!This is a

How awesome article!This is a difficult project, I'm glad you will work so hard do something you love, I am now also actively working to make a living in order to buy more dvd http://saml.xml.org/blog/recommend-tv-shows-2-broke-girls and http://saml.xml.org/blog/90210-tv-show-review

The quantity of Flag Buttons

The quantity of Flag Buttons celluloid buttons natural Coconut Buttons produced was always very Shell Buttons small compared to that of Wood Buttons other types of buttons.crystal Glass Buttons nm8ki9 For example, in 1924,Metal Buttons only 31,000 gross of celluloid Overcoat Buttons buttons were made compared to Pearl Buttons 468,000 gross of vegetable Plastic buttons ivory buttons and clothing buttons 205,000 gross of wholesale buttons fresh water pearl buttons.

This is a very informative

This is a very informative and Useful post and helps me out to get all valuable information regarding this topic. Great work. visit our website

is is very nice post and i

is is very nice post and i found it very useful for my study jual sepatu futsal nike hypervenom | jual sepatu futsal adidas nitrocharge

Great !! Thank you for this

Great !! Thank you for this beautiful Artiicle friend Best flash games العاب تلبيس بنات

World Health

World Health Organization(WHO) is definitely playing an important role for the all the developed and developing countries. "Health is Wealth" and We all have to remember this. Proper health treatment will help to have a good and disease free health. Health issues can be resolved by proper health care.

Actually I am not habituate

Actually I am not habituate to reply a comment on blogs but this blog caught my attention and I am compelled to write a comment here to express my gratitude to you. I would like to appreciate for this awesome work.. here